Stupid People Use Lawyers

Phil @ A Very Public Sociologist is dead right about this-

Personally, I have very little time for the politics peddled on HP. Warmed over social democracy plus humanitarian imperialism plus trenchant Zionism do not suit my radical palate. But they have as much right to push their rubbish politics as any other blogger, regardless of how distasteful they can be at times. So down with the complaints, the writs and the threats of court action, and away with those of censorious intent. If you’re stupid enough to make the kind of mistake Jenna Delich did, then you should take the blowback on the chin, not scrabble around for a lawyer’s latter.

As far as I can see Ms. Delich used/passed on a link to David Duke’s site, his name was in the url! I am not a fan of the Israel right or wrong position but if your opposition to the policies of the state of Israel encompass neo-Nazi scumbag retards then you need to ask yourself some very hard questions about personal anti-Semitism. Even as a simple mistake it really doesn’t pass muster, to even bother reading those sites suggests a lack of awareness of the white supremacist movement and that really is dreadful ignorance at best, at worst, well that kind of opposition is worthless as it is based in prejudice. Principled opposition to Israel’s policies involve in part opposition to racism and that anti-racism applies just as equally to racists who hate Jews but clothe it in objections to Israel. Every person who is critical of Israel has to be keenly aware that others might base that criticism in bigotry and so a due diligence is necessary to make sure those racists have absolutely no part in your politics. You can’t fight one kind of racism with another.

I’m sure Harry’s Place were gleefully making hay from the link, but it is something to justifiably make note of, having them shut down is wrong. After all a handful of witless buffoons will have to find something to fill their pointless lives with while it is down, innocent members of the public risk being accosted by an HP reader in need of idiot conversation, no one deserves that. Won’t someone think of the children!

6 Responses to “Stupid People Use Lawyers”

  1. News on Harry’s Place - 26 August 2008 « ModernityBlog Says:

    [...] Update 6: Luke warm support from 10 percent. [...]

  2. Dave (The Void) Says:

    Principled opposition to Israel’s policies involve in part opposition to racism and that anti-racism applies just as equally to racists who hate Jews but clothe it in objections to Israel. Every person who is critical of Israel has to be keenly aware that others might base that criticism in bigotry and so a due diligence is necessary to make sure those racists have absolutely no part in your politics.

    Indeed, especially when you remember that 1/ a lot of anti-Zionists are rightly drawn to pointing out the influence of the Israel lobby and 2/ a lot of antisemitism draws on conspiracy theories of Jews controlling the world. We have to be careful to keep the former from being tainted with the latter. I saw an interesting article on that subject in Red Pepper: http://www.redpepper.org.uk/Anti-semitism-and-the-Israel-lobby

    At the same time, Harry’s Place is a cesspool of vicious rightwing bastards. Sure, they shouldn’t be closed down, but I don’t think the balance of power is such that we need really worry about that. Sounds like this Delich woman has gotten herself into a hole and they’ve taunted her into keeping on digging; she’ll get taught a lesson and they’ll be unbelievably smug about it forever. I don’t particularly want to join in.

  3. So sue me, Mr Cushman « Max Dunbar Says:

    [...] Boycotted British Academic, the Duke of Chaos, Ignoblus, El Nuevo Pantano, Renegade Eye, Mushkush, Ten Percent, Socialist Unity, Sarah Franco, Rosie Bell, Ben Cohen, Darren Redstar and Unitalian. I’m sure [...]

  4. RickB Says:

    Hey Dave, yes I get you.
    I’ve skimmed that article and I’ll read it again later, yep it’s an important process to keep things honest and free of prejudice.

    Yes it’s an odd position to be in relation to HP which is a horrible place but the taking sites down stuff needs to be nipped in the bud for all of us (legal firms are sniffing a market in it and our laws are dreadful). I’m sure Ms. Delich’s bad URL was used by HP to fulfil all their grandest fantasies of all opposition to Israel is rooted in ant-Semitism but given the link she used she gave them the opening and the answer is not getting the site taken down, it just feeds their need to believe they are victims of evil monsters!!!!

    However as your recent post debated I would not be bothered if say BNP sites got the heave ho, but HP are not in that category however much their neocon nonsense and stirring to avoid debate irritates.
    Wow I’ve now talked about HP far more than is sensible or desirable, let ‘em have their site back and we can all go back to ignoring them.

  5. Dave (The Void) Says:

    Wow I’ve now talked about HP far more than is sensible or desirable, let ‘em have their site back and we can all go back to ignoring them.

    Fair enough ;)


Leave a Reply